October 12, 2026

Are Singletons Really the Problem With Your Schedule?

Sahil Bhargava
Co-Founder
See What the Data Reveals About K–12 School Scheduling.
Table of contents

Have You Ever Blamed Singletons for a Low Course Fulfillment Rate?

Ask any scheduler about the biggest challenges of their job, and chances are, ‘singletons’ will be high on the list. Singletons are courses that run in only one section, therefore every other class has to bend around it. Given the rigidity singletons bring along, one would expect schools with more singletons to fulfill fewer requests. But surprisingly the data tells a different story.

We looked at singleton share against course fulfillment across 43 schools. At a typical school, 55% of courses run as single sections, with the range stretching from 35% all the way to 82%. We found that singletons aren’t an edge case. For most schools they’re the majority of the catalog.

In our analysis, 34 of those 43 schools cleared 95% fulfillment or better, no matter how many singletons they carried. One school ran 82% of its courses as singletons and still hit 97% course fulfillment. There were also schools with far fewer singletons that landed lower fulfillment.

It raises an important question: Are singletons really what's preventing schools from fulfilling more student requests, or are there other scheduling constraints worth examining?
‍

‍What Else Could Be Limiting Your Schedule?

While singletons can make scheduling more complicated, they aren't the only constraints schools need to consider. Sometimes, the restrictions that limit a schedule's flexibility are decisions that have been carried forward for years without being reconsidered.

Here are three things worth examining:

‍1. Rules that have never been documented or reviewed

One teacher doesn't teach first period. Another prefers to stay in the same classroom all day. A third never carries more than two unique preps.

Each of these might have been a reasonable accommodation at some point. But when several such preferences are treated as fixed, they can collectively limit the flexibility to build a great schedule.

2. Too many pre-assigned courses and sections

"We've always scheduled Honors Geometry in this block."

But why?

Assigning courses to specific periods, teachers, or rooms before scheduling begins reduces the number of available combinations. Some of these decisions may be necessary, but others might simply reflect how things have always been done.

‍3. The order in which scheduling priorities are accommodated

Most schools want their schedules to be student-driven, or at least strike a balance between student requests and teacher preferences.

But the order in which constraints are accommodated can influence the final outcome. If teacher preferences or fixed course placements are prioritized before student demand, how much flexibility remains to accommodate student requests?

The question isn't whether these constraints should exist. It's whether schools understand their impact and deliberately choose to protect them.
‍

What Does This Mean For Your School?

If you're a school that believes that singletons could be the reason why your fulfillment rates are lower or schedule is being compromised in some form or shape, I'd urge you to test this out.

To give you an example, a school in North Carolina ran many of its upper-grade core courses as singletons. This was hard to schedule by hand, and there was little room to absorb a conflict which is exactly the profile that should drag fulfillment down. However, their fulfillment reached 99.78%. This happened because the team ran about 15 scenarios and found that several constraints they’d treated as fixed were more flexible. A heavy singleton load, therefore, does make a schedule harder to build.

A caveat on the numbers: all schools in this analysis use ScheduleX, so the findings may not be representative of independent schools as a whole. The data also shows patterns, not cause-and-effect relationships.

Schools also differ in how they classify courses. Some include advisory and study hall in their course counts, which can lower the reported proportion of singletons. As a result, the actual share of academic courses running as single sections may be higher than our data suggests.

This distinction is worth keeping in mind, but it doesn't change the broader finding: schools with a high proportion of singletons were still able to achieve high course fulfillment rates.

Singletons are one constraint among many. How they trade off against section balance, teacher load, and the rooms you have is a separate question.

We explore these questions in ScheduleX’s State of Scheduling & Benchmarking Report, using data from 48 private schools across 18 U.S. states and territories. Check out all the findings and see how your school’s scheduling outcomes compare.

More Insights

Get the inside scoop: the latest tips, tricks, & product updates

Benchmark showing the percentage of private schools that relied on manual processes to build their master schedules.
October 28, 2026

Why Are So Many Schools Still Building Their Schedules by Hand?

Read more
Benchmark showing the percentage of private schools relying on a single scheduler, grouped by school enrollment.
October 26, 2026

What Happens to Your School's Schedule When Your Scheduler Leaves?

Read more
School scheduling benchmarks showing the number of scenarios explored before finalizing master schedules.
October 23, 2026

Is the First Schedule That Works Really the Best One?

Read more

Your questions, our 

answers

Everything you need to know about ScheduleX. Find answer to the most common question

My schedule is very complex. Can you help?

Absolutely! ScheduleX allows you to add all your rules and requirements - as complex as they come - directly into the system. Our algoirthm will then generate schedule scenarios based on these rules.

How does this work?

You can upload your school’s data, configure your rules and constraints, and our AI-powered algorithm will generate multiple schedule options for you to choose from. Alternatively, you can visualise and build your own schedule from scratch.

How long does it take to generate my schedule?

Once you upload your data, the first schedule can be ready in as quickly as a couple of hours.

Does this replace my SIS?

No, but your SIS will definitely thank us.

How many times can I generate a schedule?

Until you’re happy with what you have. No cap :)

How do I move my schedule back into my SIS?

You can export your schedule in a .csv file that can be easily imported into popular SISs like Blackbaud, Veracross, Facts and others.